Mathnasium vs Kumon vs Trapezium Math: Which Program is Better?

by Angela McIver, PhD

Blogs

My career has been motivated by curiosity about how children learn math. I have interviewed hundreds of students across the country from kindergarten to college about their experiences learning math. Through my research I found that few students are provided the rigor and repetition necessary to develop strong math foundations. I also found that when rigor is provided, it is neither engaging nor confidence-building for students. 


As a result, many parents look for alternative and supplementary math programming. When surveying the options for supporting young math learners outside of school, many parents and families come across well known and established math tutoring companies; Mathnasium and Kumon. While these programs have credibility and work for some students, their approach replicates the teaching style used by most schools, using worksheets and workbooks.  As a parent who has signed my children up for both of the programs, I have found that neither of these alternatives addressed the root causes of their challenges, nor did they provide excitement or engagement around math. 


I started Trapezium Math Club out of my home in 2009 because my children’s needs were not being met by their elementary school math curriculum, or support from other math enrichment programs like Kumon and Mathnasium. I noticed the way that math caused my children stress and confusion, and I knew they were not alone. When we founded Trapezium Math Club in 2009 our goal was to provide programming to students that was highly engaging, confidence building and prepared students for middle school math and beyond. Our curriculum, like Kumon and Mathnasium, aligns with common core standards, so that students see a direct correlation between what they are learning with Trapezium and what they are learning in school. Unlike Kumon and Mathnasium we take worksheets out of the equation and engage students in developmentally appropriate ways: through games, movement and hands-on activities. We believe in cultivating an entirely new approach to working with young students in math that engages them creatively, socially, physically and intellectually. 


Our highly qualified Math Club Leaders are trained to facilitate curriculum that has been developed, and kid tested, over the last 15 years. The curriculum is designed to establish strong math foundations through scaffolding and repetition. Club Leaders are also trained to work with students on social, emotional learning and building positive and trusting relationships with their students. Math Club is an hour long, virtual,  weekly meet up with groups of up to 4 students and 1 Club Leader. Students are grouped based on proficiency. Accompanying the club is a Math Club Kit, which has manipulatives that are used throughout the club. 


Our approach at Trapezium radically transforms the way that young math learners engage with math, fostering a positive association with math, cultivating confidence and building durable relationships. 

By Angela McIver 04 Oct, 2023
As I was meeting with my team this morning to refine our unit on fractions, we discussed how even the brightest students become confused about fractions over time.
By Angela McIver 22 Apr, 2022
As a former middle school math teacher, one of my biggest challenges was teaching pre-algebra to students who had not developed automatic recall of basic facts. The students who struggled most in my classes were those who could not quickly do math in their heads. Most elementary schools do a poor job of developing this skill.
By Angela McIver 19 Nov, 2021
For many teachers, the upcoming parent teacher conferences will be the first face-to-face meetings with parents in almost two years. Here are some Do’s and Don’ts as you prepare for your parent teacher conference.
By Angela McIver 07 Apr, 2021
It’s been more than a year since U.S. schools closed and children were relegated to remote learning from their bedrooms and kitchen tables. And, while much attention has been given to what students have lost, little attention is given to what has been gained. If there is one thing the pandemic has taught us, it’s that education models can no longer be based on a one-size-fits all approach. As educators move to re-open schools, School Boards across the country must use what they’ve learned to encourage Districts to reimagine schooling for every student.
By Angela McIver 20 Jul, 2020
The new year started off with such optimism. . . At math club we had commissioned a new Mathemagic play to be debuted in March. We were excited about the Spring Monstermathathon and had solidified our plans for summer camp. But, two seismic events turned everything upside down and forced us to change direction, resulting in the decision to close Trapezium Math Club ... and then to re-open it!
By Angela McIver 17 Feb, 2019
I often ask these students to describe what’s going on in their head when they are struggling with a math problem. I interview students who struggle in math. The students I interview range in age from elementary and middle school to adult learners in job training programs. I give students simple elementary math problems and ask them to explain how they would solve them. While these interviews have fundamentally changed the way I think about how we should teach math to struggling students, my biggest “aha” moment didn’t come from the interviews, but from a day of volunteering in my youngest daughter’s kindergarten class many years ago.
By Angela McIver 04 Feb, 2019
When I run professional development sessions for teachers, I often ask them “What do you own?” What I really want to know is, “What skill or math content do you own as a teacher and can say - with confidence - that your children will have mastered by the time they leave your class?”
By Angela McIver 07 Dec, 2018
I used to believe that older children who struggle in math do so because they did not master what was taught in elementary school.
By Angela McIver 30 Nov, 2018
I set out to develop a math program for elementary students that challenged them beyond expectations, with lessons and activities that make students want to learn more.
By Angela McIver 16 Nov, 2018
I started Dinner Table Math as a way to empower parents to build strong confident math learners at home.
}(jQuery,window.dmAPI));} jQuery(document).ready(jQuery.DM.dmcs['dmcs-3604481'] );
Share by: